Childhood is a Bad Bet

by Zoey @ Good Googs on March 24, 2010

That’s the assertion made by Elisabeth Badlinter in her new book, discussed in this article. The idea being that it’s a bit of a waste for a parent to sacrifice every part of their life for a child, given that we live for an average of 85 years and childhood is temporary. Her theory is that women get their life back by any means necessary – formula, childcare, whatever it takes – and get back to enjoying their life with a drink and a cigarette. And while I do enjoy both drinking and smoking, I do not concur with Ms Badlinter.

If you feel resentful about a sacrifice, it’s not a sacrifice. If you are continually listing all the things you are missing out on, you are not making a sacrifice. You’ve just made a bad choice, but it’s not a sacrifice. To my mind, a sacrifice is giving up something freely and willingly for something far more important.

If you don’t want your life to change, then don’t have children. Because they will change your life, regardless of whether you choose to breastfeed or bottle-feed, co-sleep or not, or use childcare instead of staying at home.

I have to say, I didn’t really relate to this article at all. Although Megan did and she raises some really interesting points here. And what Badlinter is saying is not that outlandish really. A whole swag of experts encourage women to maintain their relationship with their partner as the primary relationship, children are temporary etc. etc. And while I absolutely agree that doing things for yourself is important, and doing things with your partner just as a couple is also important, I tend to see things the other way around. Childhood IS temporary, so why would I want to miss out on it? They’re babies for such a tiny amount of time really so why outsource them and miss out on all the fun stuff?

I like being at home. If I had a choice between my pre-baby recreational activities and what we do now. I’d choose what we do now. I loved breastfeeding her. And if anything it made my life easier, rather than harder. I didn’t have to get out of bed in the middle of the night (hello co-sleeping), I didn’t have to sterlise anything and I didn’t have to take bottles and formula with us when we left the house. Both me and my husband loved co-sleeping with her. Sometimes I still go in and get her from her room so she can sleep with us. I like that our life has changed in a really big way. My husband and I have more quality time as a family because we are both not working full-time. It’s a better lifestyle for us this way.

As Megan said in her article there is plenty of time during the day for other interests – and there’s never been a block of time that I couldn’t fill up with some project or other. Whether it be working, house renovation, writing, reorganising, cooking or crocheting. But I also knew early on that I wasn’t going to feel like I was missing something by staying at home with her. Not everyone is the same of course, which is the benefit of all of those hard-won choices we now have.

And I can’t help feeling like the ideas put forward by Badlinter are antiquated. There are more choices than simply staying at home or being a high-powered career woman. You can also work from home, stay at home, work outside the home part-time, work full-time out of the home or any manner of different options. Motherhood isn’t oppressing women, the idea that we all have to fit nicely into the box of ‘earth mother’ or ‘career woman’ might be.

Say It With Facebook

  • http://www.livinglavidawhatthe.blogspot.com Seraphim

    The kind of views espoused by Badlinter make me do an internal “oh please!” As you say, we’ve come a long way baby. And in addition to your excellent point that: ” There are more choices than simply staying at home or being a high-powered career woman. You can also work from home, stay at home, work outside the home part-time, work full-time out of the home or any manner of different options. ” I’d like to add, the rather than narrowing the parameters of my existence, motherhood has broadened them. I work smarter rather than harder. I’ve worked out what I REALLY want to do rather than just settling and whilst society may have progressed alot in the past century or so, there have been several hundred centuries of mothers being, well mothers. Why is that suddenly a problem or a job description that isn’t socially acceptable?
    .-= Seraphim´s last blog ..What actually happened =-.

  • http://www.writingloud.blogspot.com Megan at Writing Out Loud

    You raise some really good points, Zoey. It’s not as black and white as Badlinter suggests, and by the same token there are sacrifices to be made as a mother, even if you formula feed or utilise childcare. Although I loved my life before having my daughter, I also wouldn’t wish to go back. It was right for me at the time, but I don’t miss it at all. This new life as a parent does take some getting used to though and some balance so that the child, the mother and the father each have time to do what they want and need to do.

    Thanks for another perspective.
    .-= Megan at Writing Out Loud´s last blog ..Motherhood: Oppressive or Fulfilling? =-.

  • Super Sarah

    Great post about a timely issue, at least in our lives it is as we are trying to figure out the balance between whats best for the children and what my husband and I need to feel fulfilled as individuals. I don’t miss my life before children, but thats because I knew what to expect when I did get pregnant, that life would change forever, but also for the better. And great to find another person who crochets! I have been looking to adopt a Granny to help me, a friend would be even better!

    • http://goodgoog.com Zoey @ Good Goog

      In fairness, so far I am only capable of crocheting things that have a general rectangular shape. Although I have started to branch out by trying out patterns. I completely agree – it’s so important to find something that is individually fulfilling (wherever that may be!)

  • http://childhood101.blogspot.com/ Christie – Childhood 101

    I think we live in an era where women have more life choices which is a good thing but when it comes to parenthood – our children do need us to be there, parenting. I have travelled, I have had jobs I loved and which bought be immense pleasure and now I choose to be a mother, with all that that actually entails. This is the phase of my life where children and family life are the priority, who knows what the next phase will be – but whatever it is, I will adapt, just as I have done so far!
    .-= Christie – Childhood 101´s last blog ..Reading First, Technology Later =-.

    • http://goodgoog.com Zoey @ Good Goog

      I went off and did all of my twenties-craziness – so I’m perfectly happy to commit this period of my life to parenting. I can’t imagine ever looking back on this period of my life and regretting any of it.

  • http://ceaselesspraises.blogspot.com Carrie

    I love staying at home, too – and I think it also has to do with your purpose in parenting – I want to stay home with my children so I can raise them to be responsible, caring adults that God wants them to be. If I live my life for myself, putting my kids in daycare so I can go relax and have a drink (I mean, not that some time for yourself every once in a while is bad, but I mean if I make those choices all the time), how am I raising my kids to act when they’re older?

    I liked your point about having more choices than just staying home these days, too. And having children SHOULD change your life, and it should change us as people and families.
    .-= Carrie´s last blog ..Tot School =-.

  • http://stay-at-home-mayhem.blogspot.com The Maven

    You said it well, girl. I’m having a difficult time swallowing the bitter pill that is ‘parenting means sacrifice.’ Is it hard? Oh hell yes, it’s hard. My own blog is filled with rants about how difficult days can be around here. But like anything, you get back from parenting what you put in. Put in 100% (like, say, breastfeeding, co-sleeping, lots of quality time, etc) and you’ll get back just as much. Put in less (like doing whatever you can to get as far away from your child and back to your ‘old life’ as possible) and you’ll get less. You’ll likely feel less satisfied, less happy with your choice to become a mother. And you’ll be stuck in that awkward place that people talk about under their breath: “Does The Maven EVER spend time with her kids? She acts like she doesn’t have any!”

    Embrace it. Enjoy it. In a few short years, it’s done. And we’ll likely spend the rest of our lives looking back on those times wishing we could have just a little taste of them again. I’d rather look back and know I gave it my all.
    .-= The Maven´s last blog ..“Why I can never seem to blog” – a poem =-.

  • http://www.science-at-home.org Deb

    I agree completely – childhood is very temporary so I want to enjoy it! In fact I’m possibly enjoying it more this time around because now I understand how exciting it all is.

    I don’t get this concept that we work on our relationship with our children OR our relationship with our husband. Of course we need one-on-one time to connect and enjoy, but I need one-on-one time with both my children, and they need it with their father as well. And part of my love for my husband is because of how amazing he is with the girls. Being parents IS working on our relationship with each other, it’s deepening and strengthening it.
    .-= Deb´s last blog ..Yeperenye caterpillar =-.

  • http://keepingmumsane.wordpress.com Treacy

    This is a great post Zoey. I stayed home with my son 14 months before I went back to work. I enjoyed it but wanted to do something else. I am so greatful to have the opportunity and will do it again with my next child.
    .-= Treacy´s last blog ..beautiful blogger award =-.

  • http://allconsuming.blogspot.com kim at allconsuming

    This old chestnut rears its head every so often. When I had our eldest son (now 12) it was in the form of ‘The Mask of Motherhood’.

    Four children, a full-time salaried position, a part-time salaried position, an extended period as a freelancer, various significant mental health incidents and I’ve come to the opinion that basically we, as women who are mothers, fall into a deliciously normal bell curve.

    At one end are those wacky women who have chaos reigning around them and remain constantly serene and absurdly happy at their predicament. They’re the ones who publish books detailing how to create your own organic garden while knitting the family’s entire wardrobe and living a pure life.

    At the other end are those going, ‘holy crap NO ONE prepped me for this fresh hell’. Some of those are eloquent enough they write about it and you know, the rest is an internet shitstorm varying from concern, denouncement and anguish to bewilderment and outrage. And everything in between.

    At the end of the day being a parent is glorious, mind-numbingly repetitive, humbling, hilarious, soul-destroying and basically every other adjective you want to throw at it. Just as you think you’ve nailed it your kid(s) go and bloody grow up and you have to shift gear again. It’s hard. That doesn’t mean it isn’t fun. It also doesn’t mean it isn’t hugely rewarding or that there are days you think, ‘man, the amount of travel and the number of shoes I could have bought had I not chosen this path’. It’s the most gray field of all so why anyone tries to black and white it is beyond me. The end.
    .-= kim at allconsuming´s last blog ..Customer Service Charter =-.

    • http://www.unlikelymama.net Amber

      ‘holy crap NO ONE prepped me for this fresh hell’
      haha TOTALLY me!!!!!
      .-= Amber´s last blog ..Anti Depressant =-.

  • http://www.unlikelymama.net Amber

    “If you don’t want your life to change, then don’t have children.”

    Perfectly said. It’s what I think every time I hear someone talk about trying to “get back to normal” after the birth of their child. Be it sleep schedules, feeding schedules, shower schedules, etc. Forcing your baby to live on your schedule almost never works.

    I find my daily dealings constantly evolving because Alexa’s needs change week to week. I couldn’t imagine trying to make her conform to my schedule. But…I’m one of those “sanctamommies” anyway :P
    .-= Amber´s last blog ..Anti Depressant =-.

  • http://www.picklebums.com katepickle

    I keep re-reading that article and it keeps making me think that about how our society seems to be very focussed on ‘everything now’…. and that if you don’t or can’t have everything now that it is somehow a terrible sacrifice, oppressive and bad for you.

    I had and did lots of great stuff before I had kids, but I’m not sacrificing my individuality because I became a mother. Just about every life choice you make involves giving up something else – I took on a fabulous full time job, which meant I could no longer sleep in and go on holidays any time I wanted. It’s not all or nothing, what I give up in one respect I gain in another.. which is just the same with parenting.

    And the point that childhood is temporary is exactly spot on. Our children are not children forever… they deserve our time, love, support etc when they need it, when they are young. There is plenty of time afterwards to travel the world and party. My life won’t stop when I am 50 and my kids leave home…in fact I am planning just the opposite!

Previous post:

Next post: